Kim then decided to do a quick search to read into Teddy’s. There wasn’t a ton of information but some reviews did say that the pizza was pretty good.
Regardless, I’d have to find out for myself.
Fast forward to a little over a month later. We decided to head over to Teddy’s, hoping that it would be open.We walked inside to a time warp, mint green vinyl booths and all! Teddy’s was empty and I’m pretty sure we were the first customers of the day. Check out the bar…After ordering, it took a while for our large pie to arrive. I can’t say it looked pretty but it did smell really good.Waka waka!We couldn’t wait to dig in and were all really impressed from the first bite! Like I mentioned above, it might not look pretty but this pizza had great flavor. We loved how the cheese and sauce melded together. Here’s a look at the undercarriage. Check out that crispy crust!
I didn’t have high expectations for Teddy’s Bar & Pizzeria but I’m really glad that I let my curiosity lead us to visit. Teddy’s is a unique place which would be pretty hard to replicate, both the bar itself and it’s interesting and tasty pizza.
After posting about our Teddy’s visit on Instagram, I received messages and comments from quite a few people. A bunch of people had also driven by Teddy’s noticing the sign, wondering if it was actually open. A handful of others mentioned how they lived close by and had no clue that it was in business.
Teddy’s Bar & Pizzeria is definitely open and I’d say that it’s definitely worth a visit!
For those of you interested in visiting, Teddy’s is located at 718 Meacham Ave in Elmont, New York.